Highgarden Real Estate
REALTOR ®
(303) 875-9292
Email Don
mobile navigation links
Highgarden

Call to Schedule a Showing

(303) 875-9292

(303) 875-9292

2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108

$725,000

Charming single-Gathering home featuring a well-manicured lawn and mature tree at 2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108

Listing courtesy of eXp Realty, LLC IDX Logo

  • Bedrooms

    5

  • Baths

    4

  • Sq. Feet

    3784

  • Year Built

    2007

  • Days On Market

    29

  • $/SqFt

    $192

Message Agent
Schedule Tour

45 Photos

  • Charming single-Gathering home featuring a well-manicured lawn and mature tree at 2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
  • Cozy front porch featuring bench seating, decorative rug, and stylish decor at 2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
  • Inviting hallway with hardwood floors and neutral paint palette at 2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
  • Elegant dining room featuring modern chandelier and large wooden table at 2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
  • Bright dining room with wood floors, modern lighting, and comfortable seating at 2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
  • Functional office space with ample natural light and stylish decor at 2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
  • View of dining room from kitchen featuring stone backsplash and black cabinets at 2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
  • Spacious living room with hardwood floors, comfortable seating, and recessed lighting at 2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
  • Bright living room featuring a fireplace, hardwood floors, and stylish furniture at 2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
  • Comfortable living room with fireplace, hardwood floors, and natural light at 2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
  • Well lit kitchen featuring wood accents, black cabinets, stainless steel appliances, and light tile floors at 2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
  • Close up of stove and microwave in kitchen with butcher block countertops and stainless steel appliances at 2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
  • Wide shot of kitchen with center island, butcher block countertops, stainless steel appliances, and a view to the living room at 2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
  • Modern kitchen with stainless steel refrigerator and microwave, and a center butcher block island at 2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
  • Kitchen with island, butcher block countertops, black cabinets, stainless steel appliances, and breakfast bar at 2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
  • Sun-filled living room with comfortable seating, hardwood floors, and view to the backyard at 2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
  • Cozy bedroom with neutral color scheme, hardwood floors, and ensuite bathroom at 2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
  • Bright bedroom with ensuite bathroom, plush bedding, hardwood floors and plenty of natural light at 2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
  • Bathroom vanity with double sinks and wood framed mirrors at 2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
  • Bathroom with tub, tiled walk in shower, vanity, and patterned rug at 2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
  • Modern bathroom features a soaking tub with tile surround and decorative plants, creating a spa-like experience at 2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
More Photos \/
  • Stylish half-bathroom showcasing a modern vanity, decorative wall art, and a view of the outdoors through the window at 2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
  • Cozy bedroom with light wood flooring, a comfortable bed, and a matching nightstand, perfect for relaxation at 2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
  • Bright, sunlit bedroom with hardwood floors, a large window offering a view of the neighborhood, and minimal decor at 2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
  • Modern bathroom boasts a sleek vanity with a white countertop, a black faucet, and a large mirror at 2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
  • Stylish kitchenette featuring dark countertops, stainless steel appliances, and mosaic tile backsplash for a modern look at 2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
  • Basement kitchenette with black countertops, stainless steel appliances, and a brick bar for a cozy entertaining space at 2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
  • Basement kitchenette featuring stone bar, stainless appliances, and dark countertop, perfect for entertaining guests at 2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
  • Elegant staircase with wooden steps and railings, adjacent to a bar area, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere at 2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
  • Spacious basement with plush carpeting, white walls, and ample room for various activities, perfect for customization at 2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
  • Spacious carpeted basement featuring neutral tones, a window, and open access to other parts of the home at 2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
  • Expansive basement area offering versatile space, a wet bar and easy access to other areas of the home at 2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
  • Modern bathroom with a glass shower, granite countertop vanity, and stylish tile accents at 2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
  • Cozy carpeted bedroom with a window, closet and neutral paint, ready for personalization at 2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
  • Bright bedroom with hardwood floors and a window, creating a versatile and inviting space at 2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
  • Covered patio with comfortable seating, perfect for outdoor relaxation and entertaining guests at 2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
  • Inviting patio with an umbrella and table, overlooking the backyard and surrounding neighborhood at 2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
  • Aerial shot of the home showcasing the well-maintained yard and neighborhood at 2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
  • Overhead aerial shot of the house highlighting the roof, driveway, landscaping and surrounding neighborhood at 2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
  • Detailed floor plan showcasing the layout of the home, including bedrooms, bathrooms, and living spaces at 2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
  • Spacious basement floorplan features wet bar, recreation room, bathroom, and bedroom at 2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
  • An accessible building with a stone and siding exterior, a tower element, and landscaped grounds at 2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
  • Covered outdoor pool with a stone brick wall and wooden beams for shade and protection at 2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
  • Outdoor tennis court surrounded by mature trees and a walking path with clear blue skies at 2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
  • Community playground with green grass, blue skies and tall trees at 2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
Less Photos /\

Tour This Home

Fri
25 Apr
Sat
26 Apr
Sun
27 Apr
Mon
28 Apr
Tue
29 Apr
Wed
30 Apr
Thu
1 May
Schedule Tour

Home Description

ASK ABOUT LENDER INCENTIVES WORTH UP TO $17,941 ON THIS HOUSE! Welcome to Your Castle in Castle Rock – 2333 Paint Pony Cir! Located in the heart of Castle Rock’s rolling hills, this stunning 5-bed, 4-bath retreat is the dream home you didn’t know you were waiting for. With over 3,500 square feet of stylish living space, a spacious 3-car garage, and a backyard built for making memories, this is more than a home—it’s your personal Colorado escape. Step inside and fall in love with the soaring ceilings, gleaming hardwood floors, and natural light that dances through every room. The open-concept kitchen is a showstopper with granite counters, stainless steel appliances, and a massive island that’s just begging for Sunday brunches or late-night wine chats. Cozy up by the fireplace in the family room or host game nights in the finished basement—this home has room for it all! Outside, take in the Colorado sunsets from your oversized patio or gather around a fire pit under the stars. With mature trees, landscaping, and space to roam, your backyard feels like a private park. Bonus features? You bet. Think walk-in closets, a dreamy primary suite with spa-like bath, smart home upgrades, and top-rated schools just minutes away. Tucked in a quiet neighborhood with trails, parks, pools, a dog park, community events, and easy access to downtown Castle Rock, this home is the total package.

  • Interior: Ceiling Fan(s),Eat-in Kitchen,Five Piece Bath,Granite Counters,High Ceilings,High Speed Internet,Open Floorplan,Primary Suite,Smoke Free,Tile Counters,Walk-In Closet(s)
  • Appliances: Bar Fridge,Dishwasher,Disposal,Dryer,Gas Water Heater,Microwave,Oven,Refrigerator,Sump Pump,Washer
  • Flooring: Carpet,Tile,Wood
  • Fireplaces: 1
  • Fireplace Features: Gas,Living Room
  • # Full Baths: 2
  • # Half Baths: 1
  • # Three Quarter Baths: 1
  • # One Quarter Baths: 0
  • Exterior: Gas Valve,Private Yard
  • Construction Materials: Brick,Frame,Wood Siding
  • Roofing: Composition
  • Cooling: Central Air
  • Heating: Forced Air

Available now at $725,000

  • Parking: Concrete
  • Garage Spaces: 3
  • Lot: Greenbelt,Landscaped,Level,Sprinklers In Front,Sprinklers In Rear
  • Senior Community: No
  • HOA Fees: $268 Quarterly
  • HOA Fee Includes: Recycling,Trash
  • Association Amenities: Clubhouse,Park,Playground,Pool,Spa/Hot Tub,Tennis Court(s),Trail(s)
  • List Status: Active
  • : jessica@sellingdreamsteam.com,720-940-3092

Neighborhood

The average asking price of a 5 bedroom Castle Rock home in this zip code is $1,413,852 (95.0% more than this home).

This home is priced at $192/sqft, which is 52.6% less than similar homes in the 80108 zip code.

Potential Great Value

Map | Street | Birds Eye

Print Map | Driving Directions

Similar Properties For Sale

1018 Mcmurdo Cir Spacious living room featuring a modern fireplace, comfortable seating, and large windows at 1018 Mcmurdo Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
$700,000
MLS# 9658175,
Liv Sotheby's International Re...
1889 Water Birch Way Charming two-story home with a stone facade, gray siding, and a welcoming front porch and a well manicured yard at 1889 Water Birch Way, Castle Rock, CO 80108
$725,000
MLS# 8943000,
Mb Team Lassen
1114 Basalt Ridge Loo... Two-story home featuring gray siding, a two-car garage, a covered porch, and a well-maintained front yard at 1114 Basalt Ridge Loop, Castle Rock, CO 80108
$730,000
MLS# 6448247,
Exp Realty, Llc
1821 Water Birch Way Charming two-story home with stone accents, a two-car garage, and landscaped front yard at 1821 Water Birch Way, Castle Rock, CO 80108
$730,000
MLS# 5719494,
Mb Team Lassen
2098 Peachleaf Loop Charming single-story home with neutral siding, stone accents, a gray garage door, and low-maintenance landscaping at 2098 Peachleaf Loop, Castle Rock, CO 80108
$750,000
MLS# 2937121,
Mb Team Lassen
7426 Blue Water Ln Charming single-Gathering home featuring stone accents, a gray exterior, and an attached two-car garage at 7426 Blue Water Ln, Castle Rock, CO 80108
$695,000
MLS# 5671668,
You 1st Realty
7812 Blue Water Ln Charming two-story home with an attached two car garage and a well manicured lawn and landscaping at 7812 Blue Water Ln, Castle Rock, CO 80108
$724,900
MLS# 9573206,
Live Real Estate
7465 Grady Cir Stunning two-story home featuring a well-maintained front yard and an attached two-car garage at 7465 Grady Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
$725,000
MLS# 7038228,
Keller Williams Real Estate Ll...
8182 Grady Cir Charming gray two-story home featuring a covered front porch, stone accents, and a well-manicured lawn at 8182 Grady Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
$725,000
MLS# 7610074,
Homesmart
1232 Berganot Trl Charming two-story home with a two-car garage and inviting front porch at 1232 Berganot Trl, Castle Pines, CO 80108
$749,900
MLS# 8269685,
Colorado Investments And Homes
7268 Greenwater Cir Charming single-Gathering home features a well-maintained lawn, a two-car garage, and a red front door at 7268 Greenwater Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
$750,000
MLS# 7085420,
Berkshire Hathaway Homeservice...
4840 Point Mesa St Charming two-story home with a two car garage and covered front porch at 4840 Point Mesa St, Castle Rock, CO 80108
$755,000
MLS# 9448366,
Century 21 Altitude Real Estat...
1170 Mcmurdo Cir Modern kitchen with stainless steel appliances and an island at 1170 Mcmurdo Cir, Castle Rock, CO 80108
$770,777
MLS# 9568770,
Exit Mosaic Realty
1229 Berganot Trl Charming single-Gathering home boasts a well-manicured lawn and an inviting two-car garage and is located in a serene neighborhood at 1229 Berganot Trl, Castle Pines, CO 80108
$779,000
MLS# 8998611,
Good Neighbor Living
1828 Aquamarine Ct Stunning two-story home with a three-car garage, charming front porch and a well-maintained landscaped yard at 1828 Aquamarine Ct, Castle Rock, CO 80108
$809,000
MLS# 1786601,
Re/Max Professionals

Nearby Properties For Sale

4757 Augustine Ct Charming two-story home with a mix of stone and siding, enhanced by solar panels on the roof at 4757 Augustine Ct, Castle Rock, CO 80108
$825,000
MLS# 2996896,
Redfin Corporation
6514 Agave Ave Charming single-story home with stone accents, gray siding, and a three-car garage at 6514 Agave Ave, Castle Rock, CO 80108
$825,000
MLS# 9051963,
Keller Williams Real Estate Ll...
6882 Oak Canyon Cir Charming two-story home with a blue-gray color scheme and a well-manicured front yard at 6882 Oak Canyon Cir, Castle Pines, CO 80108
$824,900
MLS# 2395576,
Re/Max Professionals
1526 Golden Sill Dr Inviting two-story home with a two car garage and manicured lawn on a beautiful day at 1526 Golden Sill Dr, Castle Pines, CO 80108
$810,000
MLS# 4207333,
Exp Realty, Llc
3762 White Rose Loop Charming two-story home with a two-car garage and a well-maintained lawn on a sunny day at 3762 White Rose Loop, Castle Rock, CO 80108
$825,000
MLS# 1929904,
Exp Realty, Llc
6686 Solana Dr Charming single-Gathering home features a well-manicured lawn, brick facade, and attached two-car garage at 6686 Solana Dr, Castle Pines, CO 80108
$849,900
MLS# 5103660,
Equity Colorado Real Estate
7087 Sapphire Pointe ... Charming gray two-story home with a well-manicured lawn, two-car garage, and appealing curb appeal at 7087 Sapphire Pointe Blvd, Castle Rock, CO 80108
$874,990
MLS# 2257856,
Parkhurst Realty
7258 Oasis Dr Bright, open living room features high ceilings, large windows, and a cozy fireplace at 7258 Oasis Dr, Castle Rock, CO 80108
$870,000
MLS# 2049349,
Keller Williams Dtc
6646 Merrimack Dr Charming two-story home with a two-car garage, well-kept lawn, and stone veneer accents at 6646 Merrimack Dr, Castle Pines, CO 80108
$899,999
MLS# 7380813,
Mb Vibrant Real Estate, Inc
4261 Ridgewalk Pt Charming two-story home showcasing modern architectural design and a well-manicured front yard at 4261 Ridgewalk Pt, Castle Rock, CO 80108
$898,990
MLS# 7877242,
Re/Max Professionals
4284 Ridgewalk Pt Charming two-story home showcasing a modern design, attached two car garage, and manicured landscaping at 4284 Ridgewalk Pt, Castle Rock, CO 80108
$898,990
MLS# 2588334,
Re/Max Professionals
743 Briar Haven Dr Charming two-story home featuring a covered porch, well-kept lawn, and a two car garage at 743 Briar Haven Dr, Castle Pines, CO 80108
$899,000
MLS# 6140042,
Re/Max Professionals
6506 Merrimack Dr Inviting living room featuring a fireplace, modern decor, and an open floor plan with hardwood floors at 6506 Merrimack Dr, Castle Pines, CO 80108
$899,000
MLS# 3484456,
Compass - Denver
100 Stinson Pl Charming two-story home featuring a stone facade and a spacious two car garage at 100 Stinson Pl, Castle Pines, CO 80108
$932,000
MLS# IR1030596,
Dolby Haas
3745 Spanish Oaks Trl Beautiful two-story home with attached garage and well-manicured lawn at 3745 Spanish Oaks Trl, Castle Rock, CO 80108
$950,000
MLS# 5080023,
Exp Realty, Llc

School Information

  • School District:Douglas RE-1
  • Elementary:Sage Canyon
  • Middle School:Mesa
  • High School:Douglas County

Financial

  • Approx Payment:$3,527*
  • Taxes:$5,177

Area Stats

These statistics are updated daily from the RE colorado. For further analysis or to obtain statistics not shown below please call Highgarden Real Estate at (303) 875-9292 and speak with one of our real estate consultants.

Popular Homes

City
Avg Price
Median Price
Available
Distressed
Reduced
Avg DOM
Bennett
$615,099
$489,950
105
0.0%
53.3%
64

Berthoud
$999,927
$719,900
254
0.4%
35.0%
76

Boulder
$2,385,478
$1,690,000
515
0.2%
31.7%
64

Bow Mar
$2,400,000
$2,400,000
1
0.0%
0.0%
14

Breckenridge
$4,495,480
$3,350,000
54
0.0%
48.1%
173

Brighton
$643,374
$547,000
375
1.6%
46.4%
58

Byers
$706,645
$650,000
21
4.8%
57.1%
100

Conifer
$1,215,414
$870,000
72
1.4%
44.4%
73

Elizabeth
$791,474
$699,970
232
0.4%
39.7%
65

Erie
$877,692
$799,000
321
0.0%
29.0%
66

Evergreen
$1,788,561
$1,250,000
181
0.0%
32.0%
62

Firestone
$694,160
$640,000
82
0.0%
30.5%
44

Fort Lupton
$631,061
$524,900
107
0.0%
52.3%
136

Franktown
$1,829,963
$1,862,500
46
0.0%
28.3%
64

Frederick
$542,819
$537,000
118
0.8%
43.2%
61

Georgetown
$653,317
$677,450
6
0.0%
50.0%
110

Golden
$1,506,442
$1,275,000
210
1.0%
32.9%
56

Greenwood Village
$2,571,337
$2,265,250
54
0.0%
38.9%
66

Hudson
$884,583
$760,000
33
3.0%
48.5%
76

Idaho Springs
$1,014,494
$813,950
16
0.0%
37.5%
134

Indian Hills
$1,107,189
$804,950
18
0.0%
27.8%
61

Kittredge
$616,650
$550,000
6
0.0%
33.3%
45

Lafayette
$1,166,315
$998,500
118
0.0%
35.6%
84

Lochbuie
$487,562
$494,450
48
0.0%
50.0%
79

Longmont
$1,008,972
$695,495
422
0.0%
35.5%
60

Louisville
$1,256,287
$1,172,130
81
0.0%
35.8%
65

Mead
$676,231
$589,900
101
0.0%
37.6%
65

Monument
$967,691
$834,795
104
0.0%
34.6%
54

Morrison
$1,188,864
$950,000
107
0.9%
29.9%
48

Niwot
$2,419,989
$1,895,000
18
0.0%
33.3%
62

Palmer Lake
$672,159
$620,000
17
0.0%
41.2%
53

Platteville
$867,066
$707,500
22
0.0%
50.0%
103

Sedalia
$2,586,075
$2,122,500
24
0.0%
45.8%
93

Sheridan
$425,000
$425,000
1
0.0%
0.0%
84

Strasburg
$573,217
$485,000
53
0.0%
54.7%
114

Superior
$1,092,796
$1,094,500
56
0.0%
30.4%
60

Watkins
$587,285
$544,900
27
0.0%
40.7%
65

Listing Courtesy of eXp Realty, LLC. For information or to schedule a viewing of this property (MLS# 5090388), call: 303 875 9292

2333 Paint Pony Cir, Castle Rock CO is a single family home of 3784 sqft and is currently priced at $725,000 . This single family home has 5 bedrooms. A comparable home for sale at 743 Briar Haven Dr in Castle Rock is listed at $899,000. In addition to single family homes, Highgarden also makes it easy to find Homes and Condos in Castle Rock, CO. Cobblestone Ranch, The Retreat and The Meadows are nearby neighborhoods. MLS 5090388 has been posted on this site since 3/25/2025 (today).

Message Agent

Send

Schedule a tour

2333 Paint Pony Cir Castle Rock CO 80108

Choose a day and time

You Requested

We'll be in touch shortly to confirm your tour time and other details. Please let us know how to reach you.

Schedule Tour

CLOSE

Your message has been sent!

The agent will be in touch with you in just a minute.